In 2001, Patty and David Skolnik spent nearly three years watching their only child, Michael, play victim to a broken system as a result of unnecessary brain surgery. Due to medical error caused by negligence and incompetence, routine expectations of our healthcare system proved ineffective in providing quality medical care and patient safety for 22 year old Michael Skolnik.
When physicians provide poor quality care, their patients are typically the last to know. Some physician backgrounds may be available in your state, but can you tell which ones have the most complaints, malpractice claims or disciplinary actions? Knowing the background information on your doctor could save your life. Consumers Union Safe Patient Project is petitioning the California Medical Board to require doctors who have been put on probation by the medical board inform their patients about their status. Follow our campaign on Twitter by looking up the hashtag #DocsOnProbation.
Consumers Union Documents
- Media Coverage of CU’s Petition to require CA doctors disclose if they are on probation
The petition requiring doctors notify patients when they are on probation garnered extensive media throughout California.
- CA Medical Board Petition: Require that Physicians on Probation Inform their Patients of the Physicians’ Probation Source: Consumers Union (Thursday October 8, 2015)
Petition to the California Medical Board requesting doctors on probation notify patients of their status.
- CA Doctors on Probation as of 9-29-15 Source: Medical Board of California (Thursday October 8, 2015)
- Sign Docs on Probation Petition
Click the link to sign our petition requesting the CA medical board require doctors notify their patients if they are on probation.
- Find out if your doctor takes payments from drug companies Source: Consumer Reports (Thursday October 30, 2014)
This Tuesday the federal government under the Physician Payment Sunshine Act, as part of the Affordable Healthcare Act, began to release details of payments from pharmaceutical and medical device makers to doctors and teaching hospitals for promotional speaking, consulting, meals, travel, research, and other activities. Research shows these payments influence doctors in their choice of treatments.
Consumers Union News Releases
- California Medical Board Takes Action on Consumers Union’s Doctors on Probation Petition
Board decides not to require all doctors on probation to notify patients; passes motion to develop plan for ensuring public is better informed.
- Consumers Union Petitions California Medical Board to Require Doctors on Probation to Notify Their Patients
Nearly 500 California Doctors Are on Probation But Patients Are Kept in the Dark
- Supreme Court Decision Could Alter Composition of State Medical Boards and Include More Public Members
Three consumer organizations call for state Attorneys Generals to take action based on a Supreme Court decision earlier this year. The decision could lead to changing the make up of medical boards (and other boards) to consist of a majority of public members rather than a majority of doctors.
- Consumers Union To Hold “Ending Medical Harm” Conference at Columbia University On November 6th
CONSUMERS UNION NEWS RELEASE For Immediate Release: Tuesday, October 29, 2013 Contact: Michael McCauley, email@example.com or 415-902-9537 (cell) or Ross Moonie, firstname.lastname@example.org or 917-690-5713 or Joe Duraes, email@example.com or 914-293-0100 Consumers Union To Hold “Ending Medical Harm” Conference at Columbia University On November 6 Conference To Focus on Tackling The 3rd Leading Cause of Death Continue Reading
- California Medical Board reforms needed
Monday, March 11, 2013 Consumers Union Urges California to Adopt Medical Board Reforms to Improve Oversight of Centers and Problem Physicians State Lawmakers Begin Sunset Review of the Medical Board of California SACRAMENTO, CA – Consumers Union, the policy and advocacy arm of Consumer Reports, urged state lawmakers today to implement a number of Continue Reading
- Medical Board of California: Every Patient Must Know if Their Doctor is on Probation to Make an Informed Decision
Suzan Shinazy, retired RN and Patient Safety Advocate with Consumers Union’s California Safe Patient Project explains how many consumers cannot access medical board information online, and why the California medical board should require doctors to provide their probation status to patients at the place of business.
- Docs on Probation: Over 5,100 Californians’ signatures presented to Medical Board of California
Consumers Union’s Safe Patient Project Director, Lisa McGiffert, presented over 5,100 Californians’ signatures to the Medical Board of California.
- A Tale of Two State Agencies: A Story of a Doctor on Probation
Docs on Probation guest post by Michele Monserratt-Ramos, an activist with Consumers Union California Safe Patient Project.
- Surgeon Scorecard: ProPublica Releases Complication Rates of 17,000 Surgeons Nationwide
ProPublica, an investigative non-profit newsroom, has released a new report publicizing the comparative individual data of the complication rates of upwards of 17,000 surgeons.
- Safe Patient Activist Calls Attention to #DocsOnProbation Campaign in New Op-Ed
Marian Hollingsworth, an invaluable member of our California Safe Patient Network and active with our Docs on Probation campaign, is broadcasting our ongoing fight for patient safety in a new op-ed published by the Sacramento Bee.
- Media Coverage of CU's Petition to require CA doctors disclose if they are on probation Source: Consumers Union (Friday October 30, 2015)
Links to articles covering the issue of doctors on probation and whether they should tell patients.
- Your doctor’s on probation: Should you be told? Source: Sacramento Bee (Monday October 19, 2015)
Nearly 500 California doctors are on probation for varied offenses, including substance abuse, medical negligence or sexual misconduct. Consumers Union wants those doctors to inform patients in writing, by phone and on posted notices.
- Group Pressures Medical Board of Calif. on Probation Transparency Source: California Healthline (Monday October 19, 2015)
Consumers Union has filed an administrative petition calling on the Medical Board of California to require physicians on probation to notify patients of their status, the Sacramento Business Journal reports. A public hearing on the issue is expected for Oct. 30, 2015
- Watchdog Wants California Patients To Know If Their Doctor Is On Probation Source: CBS Scramento (Friday October 16, 2015)
“Hundreds of California physicians are on disciplinary probation for misconduct, and almost two dozen are right here in the Sacramento area.”
- Deadly infections from medical scopes go unreported, raising health risks Source: USA Today (Thursday August 6, 2015)
“for every duodenoscope-related illness that’s reported, countless others go uncounted, an ongoing USA TODAY investigation finds.”
Research and Reports
- Mapping the Terrain of Graduate Medical Education: A Patient's Perspective, Helen Haskell, MA Source: Journal of Graduate Medical Education (Thursday October 2, 2014)
Helen Haskell (2014) Mapping the Terrain of Graduate Medical Education: A Patient’s Perspective. Journal of Graduate Medical Education: September 2014, Vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 437-459.
- What to Do if You Have a Concern about the Quality of Care from a Connecticut Doctor Source: Informed Patient Institute (Tuesday September 30, 2014)
This tip sheet explains steps you can take in your doctor’s office to deal with your concerns about quality. It also tells you how to contact places that regulate or oversee doctors.
- Patient Safety America Newsletter (March 2014) Source: Patient Safety America (Friday February 28, 2014)
Summary from John James: “Spring’s renewal of life has arrived in my neighborhood with robins hopping around and trees budding. I saw a spectacular red-bud tree yesterday near a bayou. One must hope that our country will renew its efforts to intelligently manage the way healthcare is delivered in America. As far as I can tell the non-system is not working well for anyone but a few medical specialists. This month’s newsletter addresses the following topics:
• Continuing efforts to identify and discontinue worthless tests and treatments
• The over use of Pap tests in older women
• The failure of renal artery stenting to add value to optimal medical treatment
• Welcome evidence that patient safety is improving in some instances
• Trust and mistrust of medical guidelines
• The case for less mammography screening
• Ways smoking can be further reduced
• Troubled peer review in VA hospitals
• The case for improving management of obesity in very young children
I might note that just as this issue was “going to press” the Houston Chronicle ran a front page story called “Preschooler Obesity Plunges.” It explained that there has been a 43% drop in obesity rate in 2-5 year old children during the past decade.”
- Patient Safety America Newsletter (October 2013) Source: Patient Safety America (Wednesday October 2, 2013)
Summary from John James: “These are frustrating days in our country because it seems that anyone left in the middle ground on major political issues is rare, or at least they dare not speak. As we chide Congress for its ineptness, we must acknowledge that we put those people there, and in most cases they reflect what we want.
This month I was honored to have my new estimate of harm to hospitalized patients, which was published in the September issue of the Journal of Patient Safety (http://journals.lww.com/journalpatientsafety/pages/articleviewer.aspx?year=2013&issue=09000&article=00002&type=abstract), picked up Marshall Allen of Pro Publica (http://www.propublica.org/article/how-many-die-from-medical-mistakes-in-us-hospitals). He brought validity to my estimate by asking MDs in the patient safety community what they thought of my work. I have marked his and other sources that wrote about the new estimate with an asterisk in my “SitesLinks” collection this month. There are many examples of medical care gone bad.
October’s newsletter deals with 1) over-diagnosis of mental illness, 2) the secrets of the medical industry, 3) how unintended consequences can occur when physician performance is measured, 4) the death toll on women from painkillers, 5) the need to stop calling so many things cancer, and 6) the issues associated with high blood pressure and too much sodium.”
- Patient Safety America Newsletter (August 2013) Source: Patient Safety America (Saturday August 3, 2013)
This month is the 5 year anniversary of the first issue of Patient Safety America Newsletter. In those years of reading medical journals and writing to inform patients of the hazards of medical care, I have learned some difficult realities.
Perhaps foremost is that when people want to believe that their healthcare system is safe and just, their opinions are not going to be easily swayed by data and facts, regardless of how reliable the source may be. Secondly, people want to believe that physicians always have their interest at heart; this naïve supposition is not easily replaced by caution when seeking medical care. Thirdly, most people are less interested in preventing their own poor health than getting treatment when a preventable disease has gotten the best of them. Finally, most people cannot view the healthcare industry in terms of how it affects less fortunate Americans – for them it is about me and my healthcare.
This month’s newsletter speaks about questionable drug prescribers, important new views of salt and high blood pressure, cautions for those with sleep apnea, unstable relationships between doctor and patient, and finally why can’t we pay more attention to disease prevention.